Giving Back to the Community Series: Installment Five
The Giving Back to the Community Series examines the benefits of charitable giving from the donor and their family's perspective and sheds light on three common strategies. The series will include five separate articles dealing with:
Installment One: What charitable giving can mean to you and your family
Installment Two: How A Private Family Foundation Works
Installment Three: What is a Donor Advised Fund
Installment Four: The Use of a Charitable Remainder Trust
Installment Five: Compares the three methods for you to consider when deciding on how to give back to the community
Now, more than ever, we need all of us to expand our charitable giving, and Dunham hopes this series helps.
858 964 - 0500
Life's most persistent and urgent question is, "What are you doing for others?"
Martin Luther King, Jr.
These wonderfully inspiring words were spoken at a Mobile, Alabama, gathering by Martin Luther King, Jr. in 1957.
In this five-part series on giving back to the community, we encouraged you to ask what you could do in your neighborhoods, community, and for the planet to make them better. We, in essence, posed the question, "What are you doing for others?" for you to consider. The most potent force for change is what you decide to do today for others, especially for the most vulnerable.
In the four preceding articles, we examine what charitable giving could mean to you and your family, and then we explored three specific ways of giving back to your community:
- Private Family Foundation
- Donor Advised Fund
- Charitable Remainder Trust
In this final article of the series, we will compare these three methods of giving to provide guidance as to which might be suitable for you and your family. We have also created a chart that will compare these three methods, and you can download a printable version of the chart by clicking here.
While this article will assist in determining a course of action, please keep in mind that we have not covered everything. The rules are complex, and your outcome can vary based on your situation. Charitable giving is personal to your situation, and you should not seek a cookie-cutter approach.
I strongly recommend that before you decide which method is best, you speak to your financial advisor or Dunham Trust Company at 858 964 – 0500, and please feel free to ask to speak directly to me.
Charitable Remainder Trust
Let us start with the Charitable Remainder Trust, which has one feature that the other two lack. It can provide economic benefits beyond the tax deduction and capital gain elimination at the point of sale.
It can provide income for your lifetime or a specific number of years. Please see important disclosures at the end of this article.
At Dunham Trust Company, we see many charitably inspired families whose financial situation does not lend itself to making large irrevocable gifts to a Donor Advised Fund or a Private Family Foundation. The primary reason is that they still depend on their assets for income or retirement.
When you still need to receive an economic benefit from the asset but want to earmark it for making the world a better place, this is where the Charitable Remainder Trust could be the correct solution. It provides income today but could be a meaningful charitable gift when you pass away.
When you combine a Donor Advised Fund with your Charitable Remainder Trust, you can create a legacy that can continue in perpetuity. To better understand this concept, please see this article Combining Two Powerful Gifting Strategies: The Charitable Remainder Trust and the Dunham Donor Advised Fund.
When to Choose a Donor Advised Funds vs. Private Family Foundations?
Donor Advised Funds and Private Family Foundations allow you to donate cash or assets today, receive an immediate tax deduction, and give it to the organizations you want to support over time.
I read articles stating that the most significant difference between and Donor Advised Fund and a Private Family Foundation is that a Donor Advised Fund is a simpler solution to implement, but it does not allow as much flexibility as a Private Family Foundation.
This view is valid for the most part, but it might be somewhat basic as there are many other factors to consider.
Please see our second series installment for a refresher on a Private Family Foundation by clicking here.
Please see our third series installment for a refresher on a Donor Advised Fund by clicking here.
Please see our fourth series installment for a refresher on a Charitable Remainder Trust by clicking here.
The Dunham Trust Company Charitable Giving Comparison Chart
Dunham Trust Company has created a chart comparing the three charitable vehicles highlighted in this series.
- Private Family Foundation
- Donor Advised Fund
- Charitable Remainder Trust
To download a printable copy of this chart, click here.
The comparison chart examines various factors to consider, including:
- Ease of establishing
- Start-up time
- Setup and administrative costs
- Minimum donations needed
- Estate considerations
- Economic benefits to the donor
- Minimum annual payouts
- Tax deduction allowed
- The amount of deduction allowed for the year you made the gift
- Income tax on the assets within the charitable vehicle
- Amount of IRS scrutiny
- Annual tax filings
- Annual record keeping
- Ability to give beyond 501 c 3 organizations
- Salaries and travel expenses paid by the charitable vehicle
Indeed, these are not the only consideration, but they can make it easier to embark on the right road for you and your family. They can prepare you for your discussion with a financial advisor, attorney, or CPA.
One final thought. Using multiple Charitable Vehicles.
As we mentioned earlier, combining a Charitable Remainder Trust with a Donor Advised Fund could be a powerful combination if you which to leave a lasting legacy.
The same applies to a Private Family Foundation and a Donor Advised Fund, as they can also be used as complementary vehicles.
As indicated on the comparison chart, donations made through a Private Family Foundation are a matter of public record, while a grant from is Donor Advised Fund can be anonymous. If you wish to make an anonymous donation to avoid public scrutiny or do not want to be solicited by similar organizations you are gifting to, the complementary nature of these two vehicles is simple. Your Private Family Foundation would grant to your Donor Advised Fund. You would then direct your Donor Advised Fund to make an anonymous contribution to the organization you want to help.
Fulfilling the 5% Expenditure Rule
In a year where you run the risk of falling short of the 5% expenditure rule for a Private Family Foundation, use a Donor Advised Fund to fulfill this requirement.
Creating What Could be Better Deductions
A Donor Advised Fund generally has better income tax deduction rules than a Private Family Foundation. As the Dunham Trust Company comparison chart indicates, working with your CPA to determine the better tax situation for your family in any tax year could make having both vehicles available an advantage.
Taking Advantage of the Tax-Free Nature of a Donor Advised Fund
A Donor Advised Fund allows earnings within the fund to grow tax-free, whereas a Private Family Foundation has an excise tax on the net investment income of 1.39%. While this tax is more of a nuisance, for significant assets earmarks for a few years in the future, moving them to a Donor Advised Fund can create an advantage.
Preparing the Future Leaders of a Private Family Foundation
Allowing the next generation to manage the Donor Advised Fund gives them hands-on experience that will be valuable when they later take their seat as the decision-makers for the family foundation.
When determining the best vehicle to give back to your community, you need to review your goals for the assets used and work with your advisor team to review the pros and cons of each charitable vehicle or their use in combination with each other.
We hope the Giving Back to the Community Series has shed some light on how you can make a difference for individuals and our beautiful planet. We hope you can see how the impact can be significant when combined with others who also have similar goals.
We encourage you to seek from qualified professionals regarding all, personal finance issues.
Charitable Remainder Trust: This communication is general in nature and provided for educational and informational purposes only. It should not be considered or relied upon as legal, tax, or investment advice, an investment recommendation, or a substitute for legal or tax counsel. Any investment products, services, and examples named herein are hypothetical and for illustrative purposes only and should not be considered an offer to buy or sell or an investment recommendation for any specific security, strategy, or investment product or service. Always consult a qualified professional or your own independent financial professional for personalized advice or investment recommendations tailored to your specific goals, individual situation, and risk tolerance.
IRS Circular 230 Disclosure: To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein.
Federal and state laws and regulations are complex and subject to change, which can materially impact your results. Charitable deductions at the federal level are available only if you itemize deductions. Rules and regulations regarding tax deductions for charitable giving vary at the state level, and laws of a specific state or laws relevant to a particular situation may affect the applicability, accuracy, or completeness of the information provided. Dunham Associates & Investment Counsel, Inc. ("Dunham") cannot guarantee that such information is accurate, complete, or timely; and disclaims any liability arising out of your use of, or any tax position taken in reliance on, such information. Always consult an attorney or tax professional regarding your specific legal or tax situation.
The trust is subject to the published fee schedule at the time the trust is established.
There are two types of CRTs, Charitable Remainder Annuity Trusts (CRATS) and Charitable Remainder Unitrusts (CRUTs). Both CRATs and CRUTs require that the payments be made to designated individuals for their lifetimes or a fixed term not exceeding 20 years.
Because the annuity payments from CRATS are fixed and must immediately begin after the creation of the trust, the underlying assets within the structure must be kept highly liquid.
Income tax consequences for the donor can be complex, depending on the individual situation. All or some of the income from the trust may be taxed at ordinary income rates, but part may be taxed at lower capital gains tax rates or may even be tax-free for some years.
Donor Advised Fund: A donor advised fund is a separately identified account that is maintained and operated by a section 501( c)(3) organization, and is not a registered investment company.
Contributions to a Donor-Advised Fund are irrevocable contributions. Individuals considering a contribution to a Donor-Advised Fund should consult their legal and tax advisors regarding deductions, based on their personal considerations.
Administrative services fees and other fees may apply. There may be additional fees charged by the Financial Advisor that is separate from the administrative and impact investment fees.
Dunham & Associates Investment Counsel, Inc. is a Registered Investment Adviser and Broker/Dealer. Member FINRA / SIPC. Advisory services and securities are offered through Dunham & Associates Investment Counsel, Inc. Trust services offered through Dunham Trust Company, an affiliated Nevada Trust Company.Subscribe to the Dunham Blog